Pre-1925 Historic Homes for Sale

View historic properties for sale throughout Lancaster County and surrounding areas.  Should you have questions, require additional information, or desire a private viewing on any property, please give us a call or text, or use the showing button on the property.  We are pleased to assist you with all of your real estate needs.

Found: 108
Avg: $594,476
Avg $ SqFt: $207
Search Area: Adamstown, Akron, Bainbridge, Bart, Bird In Hand, Bird-in-hand, Christiana, Columbia, Conestoga, Denver, Drumore, East Earl, East Petersburg, Elizabethtown, Ephrata, Ephrata Twp, Gap, Gordonville, Holtwood, Honey Brook, Honeybrook, Kinzers, Kirkwood, Lancaster, Lancaster Twp, Landisville, Leola, Lititz, Manheim, Marietta, Maytown, Millersville, Mount Joy, Mountville, Mt Joy, Mt Joy Twp, Narvon, New Holland, New Providence, Nottingham, Paradise, Peach Bottom, Pequea, Providence Twp, Quarryville, Reinholds, Ronks, Stevens, Strasburg, Terre Hill, Washington Boro, West Earl Twp, Willow Street
Price: $200,000 to $100,000,000
Show:
View:  
  Page 1 of 5  
 
$201,000
220 STONY BATTERY RD, Landisville PA 17538
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,023
SQFT
$99
$/SQFT
0.45
ACRES
1900
BUILT
"Own a large traditional style farm house right outside of Salunga. This lovely home is in need of some TLC but is move in ready. The current owners are ready to hand the keys over to more energetic buyers with handy hands. Home has many unique features, high ceilings and large rooms that gives everyone the space to relax in the home. Nice country kitchen that has an island for prepping, Formal dinning room for all those dinners and large family room to gather before and after. The owners believe there is hardwood floors on the first floor, Second floor has carpet. Large backyard that back drops to a line of trees. Major highway is within minutes drive and close to shopping and Hempfield Schools. Home many has great possibilities, will make for a great place to raise a family."
* PRICE LOWERED - $204,900 TO $201,000 
$204,900
45 SPENCER AVE, Lancaster PA 17603
4
BEDS
1
BATHS
1,600
SQFT
$128
$/SQFT
0.10
ACRES
1919
BUILT
"How about this really nice single home in Hamilton Park Area. Updated Central Air, Electric , Gas Furnace in 2017. Great front porch. 2 Off street parking spaces.. Fenced yard. Nice city living. Fireplace in living room. 4 bedrooms,. Check it out"
* NEW LISTING  * PRICE LOWERED - $212,500 TO $204,900 
$204,900
549 E MARION ST, Lancaster PA 17602
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
1,384
SQFT
$148
$/SQFT
0.02
ACRES
1895
BUILT
"Beautifully redone home for easy updated living! Open first floor with hardwood floors throughout. High ceilings, recessed lighting and end unit extra windows gives an airy feel to the space. Open walk in pantry, gorgeous new kitchen cabinets and new stainless appliances. Half bath off of kitchen area. Second floor master bedroom with master bath attached. Shiplap, tile, granite and hardwoods can be found in this beauty. Numerous updated mechanicals. Ample street parking. Off street parking can be purchased in addition, see MLS #PALA114622 for the 4 garage spaces adjacent at 130 N Marshall St."
* PRICE LOWERED - $215,000 TO $204,900 
$207,900
1606 COLUMBIA AVE, Lancaster PA 17603
3
BEDS
1
BATHS
1,596
SQFT
$130
$/SQFT
0.11
ACRES
1925
BUILT
"Classic Cape just waiting for you! Move in condition with new roof, drywall, paint, flooring throughout! Large rooms including Formal Living & Dining Rooms. Large Stone fireplace in Living Room. Nice sized bedrooms and bath upstairs. Oversized 1 car garage with opener, also with new drywall, paint and roof!"
* PRICE LOWERED - $212,900 TO $207,900 
$209,900
664 W WALNUT ST, Lancaster PA 17603
5
BEDS
2
BATHS
2,086
SQFT
$101
$/SQFT
0.03
ACRES
1908
BUILT
"Welcome to 664 W Walnut St! Beautiful NW Lancaster City row home that has been extremely well maintained. Enter into the spacious Living Room equipped with remote controlled gas fireplace and tall ceilings. Continue into the formal dining room which boasts lots of natural light. Efficient kitchen layout and convenient first floor powder room round out the first floor! Second floor hosts three generous sized bedrooms and full bath including the spacious master bedroom with replacement windows. Third floor hosts two additional bedrooms. Large basement with plenty of storage, new high efficiency gas boiler and updated electric. Walking distance to Buchanan Park, coffee and Ice Cream shops, schools and dining. This home has so much to offer and is a must see for anyone looking to partake in the growing Lancaseter City market! Showings start 3/10 with an Open House 3/10 from 1-3 PM!"
$210,000
87 RIDGE AVE, Ephrata PA 17522
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
2,143
SQFT
$98
$/SQFT
0.57
ACRES
1925
BUILT
"Welcome Home to this sweet Cape Cod in a country setting! Overlooking a little more than half an acre with beautiful wooded views, this home has great features like a new roof, replacement windows, newer mini-splits that offer Central A/C and heat, detached 2-car garage with a terrace on top that you access through the dining room, and don't forget to check out the beautiful mural on the back side of the garage! This home is spacious with a lot to offer and with a few cosmetic updates to make it your own, it will shine! Sellers are offering a 1 year Eagle Premier Plan First American Home Warranty (valued at $585) for the Buyer of this home."
* PRICE LOWERED - $220,000 TO $210,000 
$210,500
220 W FRONT ST, Marietta PA 17547
5
BEDS
3
BATHS
2,392
SQFT
$88
$/SQFT
0.24
ACRES
1870
BUILT
"BUILT IN 1870 BY LUMBERMAN CALVIN SCHAFFNER AS A DOUBLE HOME. RESTORED IN 1970'S ADDING FEDERAL STYLE ELEMENTS TO GIVE AN EARLIER APPEARANCE. TIN WALL SCONCES, LANTERNS, AND CHANDELIERS. 4 BEDROOMS, 2.5 BATHS, SEVERAL ''EXTRA'' ROOMS FOR OFFICE, DEN OR LIBRARY. HUGE SCREENED REAR PORCH, WOODEN DECK, BRICK PATIO, HOT TUB INCLUDED, LARGE FIREPLACE IN FIRST FLOOR FAMILY ROOM. WOOD FLOORS, SOME PAINTED IN FEDERAL STYLE. PROFESSIONALLY LANDSCAPED YARD. ADJACENT TO NORTHWEST RIVER TRAIL!! HOME HAS BEEN ON MARIETTA CANDLELIGHT TOUR. PART OF NATIONAL REGISTER DISTRICT, BUT NO LOCAL RESTRICTIONS. 100 YEAR FLOOD PLAIN, WILL REQUIRE FLOOD INSURANCE."
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $215,500 TO $210,500 
$214,900
79 W MAIN STREET, Adamstown PA 19501
5
BEDS
2
BATHS
3,716
SQFT
$58
$/SQFT
0.12
ACRES
1910
BUILT
"3-Story Victorian style home is an absolutely unique property. Double door entry, inviting foyer with beautiful hardwood flooring, open staircase, pocket doors, ceiling fans, transom windows, deep window sills and stunning wood trim. 5 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, formal living & dining rooms, bonus room , new kitchen and first floor main level full bath. Two third floor bedrooms, finished lower level with half bath. Cone shaped tile roof peaks, large covered front porch. This truly is an amazing property."
$214,900
213 N MARKET ST, Elizabethtown PA 17022
2
BEDS
3
BATHS
1,837
SQFT
$117
$/SQFT
0.14
ACRES
1900
BUILT
"Fantastic, updated, income generating property with commercial space on first floor and a 2-bedroom, 1 & 1/2 bath apartment on the second floor with its own private entrance! Live in apartment or rent out for additional income. Four car, 28' x 20' garage, with additional office space and a half bath creates opportunity for even more income. Commercial space features two attached storage areas. New mini-split system provides heating and cooling in commercial and apartment space. All LED lighting for energy efficiency. Private backyard with room for gardening area and large deck. In the heart of Elizabethtown, this property is truly one of a kind! See also, MULTI/MLS#PALA114952, COMM/MLS#PALA114956."
* PRICE LOWERED - $224,900 TO $214,900 
$215,000
154 BLACK BARREN RD, Peach Bottom PA 17563
4
BEDS
1
BATHS
1,572
SQFT
$137
$/SQFT
0.40
ACRES
1860
BUILT
"Don't miss out on this unique opportunity for a two home property. This parcel features a 4 bedroom main home built in 1860 as well a 2 bedroom mobile home built in 2008. Two bedrooms on the main floor and a renovated kitchen are just a few of the benefits of this property!"
* PRICE LOWERED - $219,900 TO $215,000 
$215,000
317 N MULBERRY ST #101, Lancaster PA 17603
1
BEDS
1
BATHS
933
SQFT
$230
$/SQFT
1910
BUILT
"Beautiful open floor plan condo in Lancaster~s 317 North historic secure building. This first floor unit features hardwood floors, exposed stone walls and wood beams, granite kitchen with stainless steel appliances and breakfast bar, large walk in closet and detached 1 car garage for convenient off street parking."
* PRICE LOWERED - $218,500 TO $215,000 
$217,000
2044 MAIN ST, Lititz PA 17543
5
BEDS
3
BATHS
3,057
SQFT
$71
$/SQFT
0.28
ACRES
1884
BUILT
"Spacious home features 2 of everything..2 kitchens 2 laundry rooms 2 full baths 2 living rooms home was set up as a in-law quarters that is currently being used as a rental can very easily be turned back into a single home! Newer windows, mini splits for heat/AC 1000 SF addition built in 2000 home needs some minor repairs and finish work and is being sold AS IS!!"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS  * PRICE LOWERED - $229,900 TO $217,000 
$219,000
824 N PLUM ST, Lancaster PA 17602
4
BEDS
2
BATHS
1,483
SQFT
$148
$/SQFT
0.04
ACRES
1910
BUILT
"Revitalized brick home in Lancaster City~modern renovation with new open floor plan and design. Exposed brick walls, industrial exposed duct work , solid wood floors, custom kitchen with stone counters, new master suite with walk in closet, spa inspired bath with tile shower . all new eeerrry-thing!!!!"
$220,000
106 S ANN ST, Lancaster PA 17602
5
BEDS
2
BATHS
2,078
SQFT
$106
$/SQFT
0.07
ACRES
1890
BUILT
"Classic Lancaster City home built in 1890 has been lovingly remodeled top to bottom, yet maintains all of its historic charm! Breathtaking double front doors lead to a grand vestibule and foyer with original staircase. Huge living room with tons of natural light and a gas fireplace is perfect for entertaining. The formal dining room has original swinging doors and large windows. The kitchen is every cooks dream featuring granite counter tops, pantry, large island, SS appliances, and tons of cabinet space. The entire first floor features 10ft ceilings, bamboo flooring, and original woodwork throughout. Take the back staircase from the kitchen to the second floor where you will be greeted by a large bedroom with private balcony for enjoying coffee or an afternoon nap on warm days! The second floor also features two more spacious bedrooms, two full baths, and laundry. The third floor features two more oversized bedrooms. Other interior features that make this home special include replacement windows, all new major mechanical systems, upgraded light fixtures, fresh paint, and full basement for storage. The outdoor space does not disappoint starting with the covered front porch that begs you to sit and relax for a while. Brick pavers lead along the side of the home to a patio area for enjoying outdoor dining and campfires. The yard is your own private oasis with gardens, trees, a swing set, and plenty of space for friends and family to gather. The surrounding privacy fence will make you forget that you are right in the heart of the city, walking distance to schools, shopping, and dining. Convenient access to downtown and highways for an easy commute. Homes like this do not come around often!"
* PRICE LOWERED - $235,000 TO $220,000 
$229,000
1118 GEORGETOWN RD, Christiana PA 17509
4
BEDS
1
BATHS
2,000
SQFT
$114
$/SQFT
0.07
ACRES
1880
BUILT
"Nice 2,000 sq. ft. farm house w/32' x 50 bank barn. Located on outer edge of newer development, in town of Bart, close to restaurants."
$229,900
4847 28TH DIVISION HWY, East Earl PA 17519
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
2,160
SQFT
$106
$/SQFT
0.59
ACRES
1762
BUILT
"Stately historic home is newly renovated and ready to move in! Spacious rooms, traditional floor plan, tall ceilings and plenty of windows give this home a bright and airy feel. New kitchen and updated baths. Nice size lot features a detached 2 car garage and plenty of space for additional parking or a garden space. Come see it before it's gone!"
* NEW LISTING 
$229,900
125-B E MAIN ST #B, Lititz PA 17543
2
BEDS
1
BATHS
1,098
SQFT
$209
$/SQFT
1865
BUILT
"Desirable1st floor condoin Historic Downtown Lititz. Energy efficient gas heat with Central Air. All applinces included. Secure storage on the lower level provided. Off-street covered and open parking. No stairs from the rear entrance to elevator to condo unit. One time fee at closing =Reserve fee"
* LISTED OVER 120 DAYS 
$229,999
4847 28TH DIVISION HWY, East Earl PA 17519
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
2,160
SQFT
$106
$/SQFT
0.59
ACRES
1762
BUILT
"Stately historic home is newly renovated and ready to move in! Spacious rooms, traditional floor plan, tall ceilings, and plenty of windows give this home a bright and airy feel. New kitchen and updated baths. Nice size lot features a detached 2 car garage and plenty of space for additional parking or a garden space. Come see it before it's gone!"
$235,000
24 ROCKFISH ST, Washington Boro PA 17582
5
BEDS
2
BATHS
2,284
SQFT
$103
$/SQFT
0.60
ACRES
1880
BUILT
"Spacious 5 bedroom home with tons of character throughout, hardwood floors and architectural details. Updated kitchen with granite counters and stainless steel appliances, large bedrooms, huge deck with tons of space for outdoor entertaining and large open lot."
* PRICE LOWERED - $245,000 TO $235,000  * SHORT SALE 
$236,000
145 E KING ST #301, Lancaster PA 17602
2
BEDS
2
BATHS
1,004
SQFT
$235
$/SQFT
1870
BUILT
"Historic East Side Suites, A Condominium, just a few blocks from Central Market in the heart of Downtown Lancaster, is a unique oasis. The Historic East Side Suites boast quiet, elevated decks and private parking off E. Grant St. Own a part of history with the convenience of modern design and amenities. Completely rebuilt and modernized units within historic structures. Amenities include, all new GE stainless steel appliances with gas range, granite countertops, ceramic tiled baths, new in-unit, full-size washer and dryer, and hardwood floors. Taxes for this unit are calculated on 4.05% of the total assessment shown in this listing information and are estimated."
$239,000
37 PEARL ST, Lancaster PA 17603
4
BEDS
2
BATHS
1,734
SQFT
$138
$/SQFT
0.04
ACRES
1900
BUILT
"Modern and inviting three story home with spacious owners retreat located in Lancaster~s coveted West End. Fully updated yet historic home features exposed brick, hardwood floors, high ceilings, and a shaded backyard oasis. You~ll find yourself centrally located within walking distance of everything Lancaster has to offer including world class dining, vibrant parks, quaint coffee shops, trendy bars and restaurants, and downtown shopping. Newer roof, central air, gas heat, plenty of available parking. We are offering a $2,000 credit for carpeting. Seller has contracted to paint inside doors and trim."
* PRICE LOWERED - $249,000 TO $239,000 
$239,900
924 N OLD RD, Strasburg PA 17579
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
1,450
SQFT
$165
$/SQFT
0.28
ACRES
1875
BUILT
"Tons of Charm with this split level 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home in Lampeter-Straburg School District. The living room/kitchen area is great for entertaining with the warmth of the propane fireplace. Send the kiddos to the family room in the lower level for movies and popcorn. This home offers a lot of space for you and your family. The 18x28 garage with extra storage above is available for that woodworker or car enthusiast. *Stove reserved & to be replaced with new stove by Martin's Appliance. Home Warranty included."
* PRICE LOWERED - $249,900 TO $239,900 
$239,900
715 1ST ST, Lancaster PA 17603
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
1,812
SQFT
$132
$/SQFT
0.04
ACRES
1900
BUILT
"Exquisitely renovated townhome that boasts an open concept with meticulous details throughout.Once you open the door, you'll be greeted with gleaming polished wood floors, tall ceiling height with beautiful crown molding , shiplap , exposed brick and more. The living room boasts a gas inset fireplace for cozy nights while the large dining room offers plenty of space for entertaining. Move through to the stunning kitchen with exposed ceiling beams, shiplap and open shelving -Enjoy a cup of coffee in the beautiful breakfast nook. You'll have plenty of storage with the tall cabinetry. To the rear of the kitchen, behind the antique door, you'll find the laundry/ mud room. It is a perfect place to remove you shoes and hang your coat. There is also a half bath conveniently located for your guests.As you go upstairs , notice the stained treads and custom railings. Once you are upstairs, feast your eyes on the spectacular hand cut Turkish porcelain tiles with marble threshold in the enormous bathroom. Double sink vanity, , 7' soaker tub and tasteful subway tiles around the bathtub complete this stunning bathroom.Down the hall , you'll find the light and airy master bedroom that has a large closet with barn doors , a reading nook with Shiplap. The second bedroom has carpet and overhead light and will fit a queen size bed.A unique door with many panes leads you to the top floor that would make a perfect 3rd bedroom, study or game room.This home was renovated with a keen eye for details and it shows!This home is located within walking distance to downtown Lancaster and all the restaurants and shops."
* PRICE LOWERED - $249,900 TO $239,900 
$239,900
106 PEARL ST, Lancaster PA 17603
4
BEDS
3
BATHS
1,820
SQFT
$132
$/SQFT
0.04
ACRES
1905
BUILT
"Spectacular 4 bedroom 2 - 1/2 bath home in the desirable West End part of town.This home has been completely remodeled and is a must see! It has modern upgrades throughout the entire home, while maintaining the old city charm. Featuring an open floor plan with exposed brick and a large master suite with a luxurious and spacious bathroom. Features magnificent granite countertops, premium luxury cabinets, open floor plan, new flooring throughout entire home, high ceilings, recessed lighting throughout, new gas HVAC forced air system, Master Suite featuring soaking tub & beautifully tiled stand up shower, bluetooth exhaust fan so you can enjoy your favorite music while in your personal sauna, large private yard with new 6 foot vinyl fence (lots of potential for this yard!). The exposed brick wall in the Living room gives this home a warm feeling everyone will appreciate. Two large bedrooms on the 3rd floor with great closets! Newer windows throughout. 2nd Floor laundry room with BarnDoor:-) Master bath also features a beautiful Barn Door. Walking distance to downtown Lancaster! TRULY A MUST SEE HOME!"
* PRICE LOWERED - $249,900 TO $239,900 
 
View:  
  Page 1 of 5  
 



One Moment Please..

Please create your FREE account to enjoy all of our features!
Name (first/last)
 
Email Address
Phone


Already Registered? Sign In.